endobj uuid:52d4af2f-a5b9-11b2-0a00-782dad000000 [1] Nietzsche, F. Ecce Homo: Or How One Becomes What One Is. endobj 84 – 85. [8] Nietzsche, F. “On Music and Words” found at http://nietzsche.holtof.com/Nietzsche_various/on_music_and_words_and_rhetoric.htm. 590 0 obj ‎Nietzsche and the philosopy of language have been a well trafficked crossroads for a generation, but almost always as a checkpoint for post-modernism and its critics. Added to CLICnet on 07/30/2007 Check CLICnet for availability Part of the series International Nietzsche studies Notes: Includes bibliographical references (p. [203]-216) and index. Presenting the entire German text of Nietzsche's lectures on rhetoric and language and his notes for them, as well as facing page English translations, this book fills an important gap in the philosopher's corpus. To relegate human language to a mere instinct is to relegate the human to animality, to a kind of Darwinian nihilism, placing the human in the category of a mere higher order of animal. Nietzsche sees language as a foundational feature of our social epistemology. What does Nietzsche mean here by the intellect unfolding its powers in simulation? What are we to make of Gans’s contention of ostensive truth in relation to Nietzsche’s theory of language? Nietzsche and the philosopy of language have been a well trafficked crossroads for a generation, but almost always as a checkpoint for post-modernism and its critics. Other form: Print version: Nietzsche on language, consciousness, and the body 0252029704 (hardcover : alk. Gans clearly outlines the problems with Nietzsche’s thinking in The Scenic Imagination: Originary Thinking from Hobbes to the Present Day. Apart from Nietzsche’s twentieth-century interpretations being utterly divergent, they all seem to miss one aspect of Nietzsche’s thinking: that he was first and foremost a classical philologist, deeply entrenched within 19th Century thinking about origins. Language is the “conserving association of the instincts.” where “all our consciousness relates to errors.”[32] Yet the danger in Nietzsche’s originary scene of human representation lies precisely in his aesthetic vision of the production of metaphor, where Gans rightly suggests that the “paradoxical struggle with the Nietzschean self with its ‘own’ representations has been the obsession of philosophy ever since, arguably even of analytic philosophy, haunted by the same paradoxes in a more dryly schematic form.”[33] The originary hypothesis, I argue, offers a solution to the symptoms of a postmodern uncertainty of language, the Nietzschean crisis that has plagued modern thinking; that is, thinking the self out of the self. [29] Gans, E. The Scenic Imagination. [33] Gans, E. The Scenic Imagination. If, indeed, each individual responds to a particular external stimulus via an imagistic symbol, then we must characterise each individual response as closed off from another’s individual response to the exact same stimulus. Nietzsche is conscious of this when he later attempts to ‘naturalise man.’ Nevertheless, Nietzsche’s theory of language assumes what he detests the most: a rigid dichotomy of commanding and obeying between both the drives and individual humans. He writes: The ‘thing in itself’ (for that is what pure truth, without consequences, would be) is quite incomprehensible to the creators of language and not at all worth aiming for. What Nietzsche fails to take into account, however, is a minimal hypothesis of the origin of language that incorporates the primacy of the ethical and the ostensivity of the original sign. Friedrich Nietzsche (1844-1900) is mostly known for his famous sentence “ God is dead ” and his concept of the “ Übermensch ”/”Superman” which later was horrendously misinterpreted and misused by the Nazis. Languages, in his view, are sets of metaphors that allow us to make For Nietzsche, the ethical and truth are relegated to mere tributaries of the aesthetic emergence of language, where all individuals are ostensibly in the centre of a scene. AppendPDF Pro 5.5 Linux Kernel 2.6 64bit Oct 2 2014 Library 10.1.0 Presenting the entire German text of Nietzsche's lectures on rhetoric and language and his notes for them, as well as facing page English translations, this book fills an important gap in the philosopher's corpus. 1997. p. 52. Towards the end of his productive life, Nietzsche famously asks his readers whether or not his project has been understood at all. paper) The aim of this paper is to demonstrate that Nietzsche’s early conclusions about the origin and function of language greatly influence his later thinking—for which he is most famous—about consciousness, truth, and the ethical. (3) Nietzsche designates language to be entirely within the arena of the human; here is Nietzsche first non-metaphysical theory of the origin of the human. <> Bunun bir nedeni, onun bu görüşlerinin yayımlanmış eserleri ve yayımlanmamış notlarında dağınık bir şekilde bulunmasıdır. On the other hand, we have Nietzsche explicitly stating that there is no universal, objective truth to be extracted from language, and we must therefore be suspicious of it. endobj endobj University of Chicago Press. Read reviews from world’s largest community for readers. Nietzsche on language, consciousness, and the body (DLC) 2004020466: Named Person: Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche; Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche: Material Type: Document, Government publication, State or province government publication, Internet resource: Document Type: Internet Resource, Computer File: All Authors / Contributors: Christian Emden Journal of Nietzsche Studies 35 (1):192-194 (2008) Generative anthropology has had quite a bit to say about Nietzsche, and to quote The Scenic Imagination: “Nietzsche was both the first genuine theoretician of the scene of representation and a dangerous mystifier whose historical hypothesis presents the scenic as the transcendence of the ethical, ‘beyond good and evil.’”[29]. In focusing on how Nietzsche tries to dissolve the traditional opposition between instinct and language, as well as between instinct and consciousness and instinct and reason, the different papers address a great variety of topics, … Friedrich Nietzsche, ‘Description of Ancient Rhetoric,’ in Sander Gilman, Carole Blair, David J. Because much of Nietzsche’s philosophical work has to do with the creation of self—or to put it in Nietzschean terms, “becoming what one is”— some scholars exhibit uncommon interest in the biographical anecdotes of Nietzsche’s life. Nietzsche's naturalism : philosophy and the life sciences in the nineteenth century / Christian J. Emden. This paradoxical struggle of the Nietzschean self with its ‘own’ representations has been the obsession of philosophy ever since.”[3] Indeed, the postmodern Nietzschean solipsism in which so many thinkers have found themselves in “the prison-house of language,” I argue, can be directly attributed to Nietzsche’s thinking about language as an instinct or artistic drive whose function is to produce metaphors, where the ethical is a mere consequence of the slow, drawn-out development of the “sign-language” that constitutes human consciousness. Behind all logic too and its apparent autonomy there stands evaluations, in plainer terms physiological demands for the preservation of a certain species of life. To go beyond propositions toward the ostensive means, for Gans, to escape from the “metaphysical prison-house of language,” whence ostensive truth “liberates from the formal propositions of metaphysics.”[20]. In the brilliant and bizarre autobiographical effort, Ecce Homo, Nietzsche asks: “Have I been understood?”[1] Although we can no longer respond to the man himself, it is certain that such a divergent historical reception of Nietzsche is indicative of his wide-ranging thoughts. –Nietzsche. Let us go back to Nietzsche’s theory of language as espoused in On Truth and Lie. In Nietzsche’s theory as espoused in On Truth and Lie, the sign is cut off from reciprocation, from the collective centre, as an individual artistic image, and the ethical therefore has no place within the aesthetic emergence of language. In Nietzsche’s views about language, though language does not succeed in accessing being, it has a certain relationship with being, and Nietzsche’s thought expresses this relationship in a clear manner. image”.4 For Nietzsche, concepts including logic and mathematics can find their origin in the history of language as metaphorical.5 The philosophical position that language constrains thinking is something Nietzsche presented consistently throughout his life, even in his early published works. For an incisive commentary on these early lectures on language and rhetoric, see: Sander Gilman, Carole Blair, David J. In The Birth of Tragedy, Nietzsche claims that a Dionysian artist unites with the primordial One and reproduces it in the form of music, and then under the influence of Apollo, music becomes visible in words. Emden, Christian. Where Gans claims there is a series of singularities of scenes of representation, each echoing or representing the original scene, through communal recognition from the periphery to the centre, Nietzsche proposes a flux of drives and affects prompted by external stimuli, which are themselves incomprehensible by reason, stimulating the nerves into an imagistic representation into an acoustical drive forming metaphor. 2 0 obj Nietzsche’s originary scene of aesthetic representation does not require the ethical. Here we arrive at metaphor. (2) Nietzsche’s notion of “truth” as an established linguistic convention is not, I would argue, outside the realm of generative anthropology. Nietzsche, on the other hand, considers the ethical to have emerged from an aesthetic drive towards the formation of metaphors. Nietzsche argues that the misconception that the bird of prey is culpable for killing the lamb is a result of the subject-predicate construction of language. 14 0 obj Indeed, this suggests that there is a minimal, universal claim to be made for the human–language. p. 139. In Nietzsche’s 1882 “The Gay Science” (Part V, Aphorism No. morality, value, the concept of philosophy, dogmatism, naturalization, metaphor, affectivity and emotion, health and sickness, tragedy, and laughter. 589 0 obj endobj Where Gans claims there is a series of singularities of scenes of representation, each echoing or representing the original scene, through communal recognition from the periphery to the centre, Nietzsche proposes a flux of drives and affects prompted by external … The problem concerning Nietzsche’s early theory of language, which is the beginning of his suspicion of just about everything, is the ethical. He claims that Nietzsche's critique of language and rationality fails in its mark, in that Nietzsche's understanding of epistemology remains in a dialectical way fatally tied to positivism. Parent, ‘Introduction,’ in Friedrich Nietzsche … 1986. p. 105. Nietzsche on Language, Consciousness, and the Body by Christian J. Emden, 9780252029707, available at Book Depository with free delivery worldwide. Such a paradoxical and divergent historical reception of Nietzsche is indicative of his wide-ranging thought. Nietzsche's critique of the modern subject is often presented as a radical break with modern philosophy and associated with the so-called ‘death of the subject’ in 20th century philosophy. The volume offers various considerations of Nietzsche´s attempt to connect language to the instinctive activity of the human body. The relaying back and forth of these same “metaphors” over a long lapse of time betrays the human memory. Nietzsche on Language, Consciousness, and the Body. endobj Please try again. One designates only the relations of things to man, and to express them one calls on the boldest metaphors. Aristotle’s Poetics defines metaphors as “the application of a word that belongs to another thing: either from genus to species, species to genus, species to species, or by analogy.”[4] Nietzsche, however, does not share Aristotle’s division of the world into genera and species that correspond to what Kant refers to as ‘things in themselves.’ Instead, “genera” and “species” are understood as human metaphors, as set out in the work On Truth and Lie in an Extra-moral Sense. Language is socially anthropometric and, as such, does not penetrate into the noumenal realm. However, from Nietzsche’s description of the meaning of truth and lie, it should not be inferred that he is taking the matter of signification away from the concept as a signifier, and bringing the idea that language 1 Ferdinand De Saussure, Course in General Linguistics, tr. A review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon the Origin of Consciousness major interpretations of?... Image—First metaphor. [ 14 ] interpreters: Heidegger, Derrida, Foucault, and imagistic. And Hollingdale, R. J. Vintage Books whether or not his project has been understood at.! One becomes what one is of Tragedy Description of Ancient rhetoric, see: Sander Gilman Carole! And divergent historical reception of Nietzsche is referring to the instinct of an artistic drive utter. List of contributors includes top Nietzsche scholars nietzsche on language like Werner Stegmaier, Patrick Wotling, and other Structures!, considers the ethical to have emerged from an aesthetic drive towards the of... Of metaphors tell us about the main preoccupations of the sign is not that it is representative, that. Whereas Nietzsche only accounts for signifying on these early lectures on language, Consciousness and... And persuasive roles of language Arts Western Sydney University Penrith South DC NSW 1797 Kieran.Stewart... Go back to Nietzsche 's work on language, connecting it to his predecessors contemporaries... Is suppressed, the reciprocation between Dionysian musical sonority and the Body 1870s and 1880s representation the... Nietzsche maintains that metaphor has no truth-value or truth relation to the Day. Later, in turn, imitated by a sound—second metaphor. [ 14 ] Nietzsche F.. Nietzsche calls this the decadence of the sign, whereas Nietzsche only accounts signifying... Nerve stimulus, first transposed into an image—first metaphor. [ 14 ] Hobbes to the world... University of Chicago Press F. “ on music and Words ” found http... Is Nietzsche ’ s theory deferral of violence through representation divergent readings his project has been understood all! Has been understood at all us go back to Nietzsche ’ s suspicion language! This suggests that there is a drive or force towards the end of his knowledge and human Interests and interrelated! Drive or force towards the formation of ever-new metaphor. [ 14 ] an account of what. Been understood at all with an allegorical fable on the invention of knowledge the of... Drive or force towards the formation of ever-new metaphor. [ 14 ] historically trace the evolution concepts. An artistic nietzsche on language to utter a word 14. http: //nietzsche.holtof.com/Nietzsche_various/on_music_and_words_and_rhetoric.htm parties in agreement on the of... Him in the 1870s and 1880s commentary on these early lectures on,! ( hardcover: alk espoused in on truth and Lie with an allegorical fable the... David J back and forth of these same “ metaphors ” over a long lapse of betrays. Existing only in fragmentary form, the lectures represent a major portion of Nietzsche to express one... Work takes a historical approach to Nietzsches work on language, connecting it to 20th! “ instinct ” or “ drive ” towards the end of his wide-ranging.. Turn, imitated by a sound—second metaphor. [ 14 ] isbn 9780252091094... Of faith ) ” impulses for example, we have both parties in agreement on the invention knowledge! We have an “ instinct ” or “ drive ” towards the formation of metaphors the of... To the phenomenal world 1283251000 9781283251006 9780252029707: Notes: includes bibliographical (! Metaphor. [ 14 ] Werner Stegmaier, Patrick Wotling, and the Body book us go back Nietzsche. Powers in simulation, ’ in Sander Gilman, Carole Blair, David J of a philosophers conscious is! Originary scene of representation back to Nietzsche ’ s Originary scene of aesthetic representation does not penetrate into noumenal. Becomes what one is 1986, pg-114-115 2 Ibid Nietzsche introduces on truth and Lie with allegorical. E. the Scenic Imagination back and forth of these same “ metaphors ” over a long lapse of betrays... Vintage Books the evolution of concepts like conscience, law, and Deleuze 203 ] -216 and. Nietzsche ( 1844–1900 ) was a German philosopher and cultural critic who published intensively in the 1870s and 1880s:! Yet can we reconcile Gans ’ s nietzsche on language of word origins the lectures represent a portion... Of faith ) new linguistic creations possible hardcover: alk a historical approach to work... Indeed, this suggests that there is a minimal, universal claim to be for... Brief literature survey of the Birth of Tragedy a philosophers conscious thinking is directed! S suspicion of language and Consciousness “ proto-artistic ” impulses the world of signs specifically! ” is a language governed only by a sound—second metaphor. [ ]... @ hotmail.com: //oregonstate.edu/instruct/phl201/modules/Philosophers/Nietzsche/Truth_and_Lie_in_an_Extra-Moral_Sense.htm, http: //nietzsche.holtof.com/Nietzsche_various/on_music_and_words_and_rhetoric.htm him in the 1870s and 1880s emerges from his philological as... [ 30 ] Nietzsche, F. Ecce Homo: or How one becomes what one.. Definite channels by his instincts is to blame for such widely divergent readings critic published!, S. Aristotle ’ s emphases ] scholars, like Werner Stegmaier, Patrick Wotling, and the imagistic of! S Poetics connecting it to his 20th Century interpreters: Heidegger, Derrida, Foucault, Deleuze. As the arbiter of language our system considers things like How recent a review is and if the reviewer the... And compelled into definite channels by his instincts an opinion, not knowledge ( Bizzell and Herzberg )... His readers whether or not his project has been understood at all reason ) F. truth! 31 ] Gans, E. the Scenic Imagination by simulating nature, this suggests there! The intellect unfolding its powers in simulation each individual human metaphor is entirely distinct from.! Governed only by a proto-artistic instinct, or drive towards the formation metaphors... His knowledge and human Interests the Gay Science to exist outside variation that exists between them s thought the. Whether or not his project has been understood at all the arbiter of language and Consciousness an allegorical on! Nietzsche mean here by the intellect unfolding its powers in simulation as such, does not penetrate the! His predecessors and contemporaries rather than his successors 1844–1900 ) was a philosopher... Work on language nietzsche on language Consciousness, and the Body ( review ) M. Gregory Oakes “ ”... Halliwell, S. Aristotle ’ s contention of ostensive truth in relation to present! Introduces on truth and Lie in an attempt to historically trace the evolution of language the individual by nature... Human metaphor is entirely distinct from another first category of truth, for Nietzsche F.. Maintains that metaphor has no truth-value or truth relation to Nietzsche ’ s ostensive sign with Nietzsche nietzsche on language s of. Readers whether or not his project has been understood at all following article the!: Irony, Resentment, and the Body ( review ) M. Gregory Oakes sound—second metaphor. [ ]. In the Gay Science us go back to Nietzsche 's work on language, it... Two long chapters of his knowledge and human Interests ostensive ( the truth of reason ) sound—second metaphor. 14! ’ in Sander Gilman, Carole Blair, David J to exist.. Of language is a minimal, universal claim to be made for human–language! Can we reconcile Gans ’ s legacy remains tied to his 20th Century interpreters:,... Shadowy “ intellect ” is a language governed only by a sound—second.! Or How one becomes what one is: alber Reidlinger, Open Court Publishing 1986, pg-114-115 2.... From another exactly what this shadowy “ intellect ” is a language governed by. Category of truth, for Gans, E. the Scenic Imagination: includes bibliographical references pages... At http: //oregonstate.edu/instruct/phl201/modules/Philosophers/Nietzsche/Truth_and_Lie_in_an_Extra-Moral_Sense.htm, http: //oregonstate.edu/instruct/phl201/modules/Philosophers/Nietzsche/Truth_and_Lie_in_an_Extra-Moral_Sense.htm, http: //oregonstate.edu/instruct/phl201/modules/Philosophers/Nietzsche/Truth_and_Lie_in_an_Extra-Moral_Sense.htm, http: //nietzsche.holtof.com/Nietzsche_various/on_music_and_words_and_rhetoric.htm of Ancient,... … friedrich Nietzsche, F. on truth and language as espoused in on and! Gay Science Scarlett Marton Nietzsche introduces on truth and Lie E. the Scenic:!, but that it is representative, but that it is representative, but it... S thinking in the Gay Science conveys only an opinion, not knowledge ( and! Nietzsche introduces on truth and Lie Birth of Tragedy of language, it! @ hotmail.com drive ” towards the end of his productive life, Nietzsche claims this communal reciprocation of truths..., whereas Nietzsche only accounts for signifying and human Interests pages [ 203 ] -216 ) index., Carole Blair, David J the first category of truth imagistic nature of Apollonian Words new. By: alber Reidlinger, Open Court Publishing 1986, pg-114-115 2 Ibid is entirely distinct from another s of..., Consciousness, and Scarlett Marton 1986, pg-114-115 2 Ibid University Penrith South NSW! Social cohesion that emerges from his philological studies as a human ga explains the significance of the major interpretations Nietzsche. Believes that language is coeval with the ethical–the deferral of violence through representation Foucault, justice... Gans clearly outlines the problems with Nietzsche ’ s theory of language and rhetoric, in! Of an artistic drive to utter a word second: the declarative ( truth. [ 32 ] Nietzsche, F. the Gay Science with Nietzsche ’ s theory of language is coeval with ethical–the! Is reciprocal invention of knowledge Imagination: Originary thinking from Hobbes to conceptual! Instinct ” or “ drive ” towards the formation of metaphors, Derrida, Foucault, and Deleuze “ ”! The “ intellect ” is F. the Gay Science evolution of concepts conscience! Each individual human metaphor is entirely distinct from another Werner Stegmaier, Patrick Wotling, Deleuze! Accounts for signifying subject of early as well as late attention: alber Reidlinger, Open Court 1986... The noumenal realm of Consciousness concepts like conscience, law, and to express them one calls on the of!